Main Street Pizza Reynoldsville
Main Street Pizza Logo

Main Street Pizza

4.6716 reviews

Main Street Pizza offers a cozy spot for pizza lovers in Reynoldsville. Located on E Main St, it's a great place to grab a bite with friends or family. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming. The menu boasts a variety of pizzas, appetizers, and beverages. It's perfect for lunch or dinner, and even late-night cravings.

The friendly staff ensures quick service, enhancing the dining experience. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, convenience is key at Main Street Pizza. Whether it's a casual meal or a gathering with friends, this pizzeria meets all expectations. Be sure to enjoy their local specialties!

About

Main Street Pizza sits proudly at 474 E Main St in Reynoldsville, Pennsylvania. Known for its vibrant community, Reynoldsville is home to many local businesses. This pizzeria has established itself as a local favorite over the years. It's popular among families, locals, and even tourists.

The inviting space features comfortable seating and an energetic vibe. Accessibility options make it easy for everyone to enjoy a meal here. With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, Main Street Pizza crafts dishes that resonate with the local culture. Visitors often stop by to experience the charm of this quaint town while indulging in delicious pizza.

Get in Touch

474 E Main St, Reynoldsville, PA 15851, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 10:30-21:00
  • Tuesday 10:30-21:00
  • Wednesday 10:30-21:00
  • Thursday 10:30-21:00
  • Friday 10:30-22:00
  • Saturday 11:00-22:00
  • Sunday 11:00-21:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Small mice convient"

- kayla W.

"Amazing staff that are pleasant and helpful. The boneless wings were moist and lots of flavor. The fries were very good, and both I would order again. The pizza was good, but the top was done, and the bottom of the pizza was on the doughy side and needed to be cooked longer. It was a very hot day, so that could have played a role with the dough. I would try again to see if it was a fluke. It was good, but I have had better, and I have had worse. I would definitely suggest the boneless wings, they were some of the best wings i have had at a decent price. There was no problem finding parking, and it was a short wait. All the items were not overly prced, and they had different specials. It's been a while since I ordered food from here, but overall, I would come back again."

- Sean

"Was that a friend's house and they ordered from main Street Pizza I live in DuBois they live in reynoldsville. And I must say some of the best pizza I've ever had. And that chef salad it don't get no fresher. So then I went back yesterday in person. The service was fantastic The Establishment is clean very inviting in the staff is out of this world. The pizza was fantastic the steak Stromboli was absolutely great and the hot wings best wings in town. I will absolutely patron this business again! And I implore everyone else to do the same"

- Shaina M.

"The pizza definitely ranks in my top 5 ever. The cheese was thick and gooey. The sauce tasted great and the toppings were generous. The wings were legit. Definitely top 2 of all time. Crispy, saucy, and good size. I'll definitely be back!"

- Jason R.

"Very nice experience! Everyone was extremely helpful and polite. Food was great. No complaints."

- David D.

"Ordered there before. This time i got the buffalo chicken pizza. Just pretty much tasted like a bbq chicken pizza. Probably wont get it again. But the rest of the times ive ordered there, the food and staff has been fantastic! Keep up the good work !"

- Justin M.

"I use to eat a lot of there food younger but refuse to order there personally and don't dare be disappointed when you order onions, lettuce and cheese on hamburger and 3 pieces of small onion with 3 small pieces small lettuce but they made it so I was wrong!! I get it's been open for long time but I can't eat in a nasty dirty restaurant and needs to be updated as well. Surprised still in business actually!! Foxes will eventually take over if lower sizes of food and amounts of prices keep going up. It's rediculous and almost fair food costs but food not that good!!! "

- Sara D.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Main Street Pizza deserves a visit for its friendly service and delicious food. The boneless wings stand out for their flavor and tenderness. Many claim them to be among the best in town, and they pair nicely with a cold beer from their extensive selection. The menu caters to various preferences, including vegetarian options.

Visitors can savor delightful pizza options that feature thick, gooey cheese and generous toppings. For something unique, try the buffalo chicken pizza, although some suggest sticking to the classic varieties. The relaxed atmosphere invites patrons to unwind and enjoy quality time with friends.

For those looking to visit during less busy times, Monday to Friday before noon is ideal. Dine-in or takeout options ensure flexibility. Main Street Pizza often has specials, making it easy to indulge without breaking the bank. This is truly a place where local flavors and community spirit come together.

Most Liked things

Patrons love the extensive beer selection, which enhances the dining experience. The boneless wings receive consistent praise for their flavor and texture. Additionally, the relaxed and clean environment makes it a pleasant spot for dining. Many customers appreciate the prompt service and inviting staff.

Most Disliked things

Some visitors report inconsistency in pizza preparation, noting instances of doughy crusts. A few reviews mention dissatisfaction with portion sizes for certain items, feeling they may not represent the price point. A small number of customers highlight cleanliness issues, suggesting improvements could elevate the overall experience.

FAQ

What types of pizza are available at Main Street Pizza?

Main Street Pizza offers various options. Enjoy pizza by the slice, mini 6-inch, small 10-inch, and medium 12-inch sizes. With ten menu items, you will likely find something to love.

What are the opening hours for Main Street Pizza?

Main Street Pizza is open for lunch and dinner. Pizza by the slice is available until 2 pm, Monday through Friday. Check local listings for exact times.

Is Main Street Pizza family-friendly?

Yes, Main Street Pizza welcomes families. The relaxed ambiance and accessible seating make it an inviting choice for all ages.

Can I make a reservation at Main Street Pizza?

Reservations are accepted at Main Street Pizza. It’s a great option for larger groups. Make sure to call ahead to secure your table.

What payment methods does Main Street Pizza accept?

Main Street Pizza accepts various payment methods. Pay with credit cards, debit cards, checks, or mobile NFC payments. Enjoy your meal without hassle!